Club Redevelopment Risk Checklist

25 practical issues for directors to test, discuss and monitor through a capital project.

Use this as a board working paper

A club redevelopment involves choices about members, operations, funding, approvals and delivery. Use this checklist to request the right information, record decisions and spot matters that need further work.

Work through the items at feasibility, before a major commitment, and at regular project reviews. Mark the evidence you have seen, the owner of each action and the date the board will review it again.

Related reading: our Strategic Feasibility & Masterplanning service, and 7 Mistakes Clubs Make Before Starting a Redevelopment.

Download as PDF

Enter your details to download the complete Club Redevelopment Risk Checklist as a printable PDF.

No spam. We'll only email you about club redevelopment resources.

Financial and funding

Six issues to test in the cost plan, cash flow and funding approach.

1.Incomplete scope or site information

Early budgets can miss existing conditions, services, asbestos, structural repairs or a decision that has not yet been designed. Ask what the estimate includes, excludes and assumes.

Practical action

  • Commission investigations proportionate to the site and project stage.
  • Keep an assumptions and exclusions register with the cost plan.
  • Update the budget when the design or site information changes.

2.Revenue disruption during works

Closures, access changes and altered trading areas can affect gaming, food and beverage, functions and memberships. The effect depends on the club’s operating model and staging plan.

Practical action

  • Prepare a phase-by-phase operating and revenue plan.
  • Test temporary facilities, access and communications with operations staff.
  • Review actual trading performance against the approved forecast.

3.Funding does not match delivery

A viable project can still be difficult to deliver if approvals, lender conditions, cash flow and payment timing do not line up with the programme.

Practical action

  • Map funding sources, conditions, drawdowns and decision dates.
  • Maintain a cash-flow forecast alongside the cost-to-complete forecast.
  • Agree how a scope change or additional funding would be considered.

4.Finance assumptions become outdated

Interest, refinancing, timing and operating assumptions can change over a project’s life. Board papers should make these assumptions visible rather than treating them as fixed facts.

Practical action

  • Ask the finance adviser to explain the assumptions and sensitivity cases.
  • Reforecast at agreed decision points and after material programme changes.
  • Record who may approve a change to the financial plan.

5.Member funding is assumed without advice

The structure of any member contribution, loan or guarantee needs careful treatment. Requirements depend on the club’s circumstances and current law.

Practical action

  • Obtain club-specific legal and financial advice before relying on a structure.
  • Keep board records clear about proposed approvals.
  • Give members plain-English information before a required decision.

6.Security and valuation are not revisited

A lender’s security position and the club’s asset assumptions can be affected by delay, market conditions or a changed scope.

Practical action

  • Ask lenders what information and approvals they require as the project develops.
  • Use current professional advice for material valuation or security decisions.
  • Document the consequences of pausing, re-scoping or staging works.

Governance and decisions

Five ways to keep the board informed and its decisions defensible.

7.Project knowledge leaves with people

Elections, staff changes and consultant turnover are normal. A project loses momentum when its decisions, rationale and open issues exist only in people’s memories.

Practical action

  • Keep a decision register, risk register and current project brief.
  • Provide a short induction pack for incoming directors and project staff.
  • Nominate clear project roles and a handover process.

8.Members do not understand trade-offs

Members may support the objective but need a clear account of disruption, cost, benefits and decisions still to come. Consultation should inform the project, not simply announce it.

Practical action

  • Set out what is decided, proposed and open for feedback.
  • Use accessible project updates, forums and visuals.
  • Report feedback themes and the board’s response.

9.Board reporting is late or too high level

A board needs a concise view of cost, programme, risks, decisions and operating impacts. Narrative updates alone can make emerging issues hard to see.

Practical action

  • Agree a board reporting pack before commitments are made.
  • Show approved budget, forecast, commitments and changes together.
  • Make the top risks, owners and required board decisions explicit.

10.Conflicts are not managed openly

A director, adviser or supplier may have an interest that needs to be declared and managed. The appropriate process depends on the facts and the club’s obligations.

Practical action

  • Maintain an up-to-date conflict register and declaration process.
  • Record how each relevant conflict was assessed and managed.
  • Seek independent legal advice where the position is unclear or material.

11.Insurance is considered too late

Construction, consultant and operational risks can change as scope and staging develop. The board needs advice on cover and responsibilities appropriate to its project.

Practical action

  • Ask an insurance adviser to review the project at the right stages.
  • Confirm required insurance in consultant and builder agreements.
  • Keep insurance responsibilities and evidence in project records.

Construction and staging

Five delivery issues that benefit from clear contracts and regular review.

12.Builder financial capacity changes

A contractor’s capacity can change between tender, award and delivery. The board should understand the checks completed and protections available if delivery is interrupted.

Practical action

  • Undertake proportionate financial and reference checks before appointment.
  • Use contract security and payment certification advised for the project.
  • Keep a documented response plan for a material contractor default.

13.Defects are accepted without a clear process

Defects can be harder to resolve after final payments and release of security. Handover should be treated as a managed phase, not a single date.

Practical action

  • Define inspection, defects recording and rectification steps in the contract.
  • Use appropriately qualified inspections and commissioning records.
  • Link release of security and final account steps to the contract process.

14.Changes are approved without their full effect

A change can affect price, time, operations, approvals and later maintenance. The difficulty is approving it without a complete record.

Practical action

  • Require a written change request with scope, cost, time and risk effects.
  • Set authority levels that match the club’s governance framework.
  • Report approved, pending and anticipated changes together.

15.Programme pressure hides dependencies

Weather, procurement, design decisions, approvals and access can affect the critical path. A completion date is useful only when the assumptions behind it are visible.

Practical action

  • Review the critical path and near-term constraints regularly.
  • Record recovery actions with their cost and operational impact.
  • Give the board early warning of decisions that could affect completion.

16.Staging is not tested with operations

A sequence that works on drawings may not work for members, staff, deliveries, safety or venue trading. Operational input is essential before a phase begins.

Practical action

  • Develop a stage plan with operations, safety and project teams.
  • Confirm temporary access, amenities, signage and staff arrangements.
  • Review each stage before mobilisation and capture lessons for the next.

Planning and approvals

Four matters to resolve with project-specific professional advice.

17.Approval strategy is unclear

A development pathway, consent conditions or required specialist studies can shape scope, timing and cost. These matters need project-specific advice.

Practical action

  • Engage appropriate planning professionals early.
  • Keep an approvals schedule with owners, dependencies and decision dates.
  • Bring material conditions and their effects back to the board.

18.Heritage or site constraints emerge late

Heritage listings, archaeology and existing building fabric can affect the viable design. Identify relevant constraints before relying on a preferred concept.

Practical action

  • Confirm planning and heritage constraints at feasibility stage.
  • Obtain specialist advice where the site or building warrants it.
  • Reflect confirmed constraints in the programme, brief and cost plan.

19.Neighbour and community impacts are underestimated

Traffic, noise, privacy, lighting and construction activity may require a considered response. Early factual engagement can identify issues before they become harder to address.

Practical action

  • Use the project team to identify likely impacts and required studies.
  • Prepare clear, accurate material for neighbours and stakeholders.
  • Track issues, commitments and responses through approval.

20.Approval timing is treated as a promise

Authority processes and information requests can vary. Planning should allow for dependencies without presenting an assumed date as a guarantee.

Practical action

  • Use a live approvals programme rather than one assumed timeframe.
  • Identify which design, funding and procurement decisions depend on approval.
  • Update the board when a delay changes a material decision or forecast.

Operations and opening

Five ways to protect member experience and prepare for handover.

21.Operating approvals are not integrated into staging

Changes to gaming, liquor, occupancy, food service or access can require different operational arrangements. Requirements depend on the club, consent and licence conditions.

Practical action

  • Seek advice from relevant specialists and authorities when needed.
  • Include operating approvals and compliance tasks in each stage plan.
  • Brief managers and staff before a new stage or facility opens.

22.Licence conditions are not checked against the layout

A new or altered facility can affect how existing licence and approval conditions apply. This should be checked before works or opening commitments are finalised.

Practical action

  • Review applicable conditions with qualified advice.
  • Allow time for any required applications or approvals.
  • Keep an opening-readiness checklist owned by operations.

23.Member experience is not monitored through disruption

Members can tolerate disruption when they understand what is changing and can still use valued parts of the club. Test assumptions against feedback and trading data.

Practical action

  • Identify priority member experiences for each stage.
  • Communicate changes early through the channels members use.
  • Review feedback, membership and revenue indicators with management.

24.Commissioning is compressed before opening

Systems, kitchens, bars, access, staff training and operational procedures need testing before the club relies on them. Opening pressure should not remove the evidence trail.

Practical action

  • Create a commissioning and opening-readiness plan early.
  • Confirm test records, manuals, training and outstanding defects.
  • Agree who may accept each operational area for use.

25.The project team is working to different decisions

Misaligned roles, unclear authority and incomplete records can turn normal delivery issues into disputes. The board needs a reliable route for decisions and escalation.

Practical action

  • Confirm roles, authority and communication protocols at the outset.
  • Use coordination meetings with actions, owners and due dates.
  • Escalate unresolved matters through the agreed governance process.

Download the board checklist

Bring it to a board or committee meeting, note the evidence requested and use it to track follow-up actions.

Download as PDF

Enter your details to download the complete Club Redevelopment Risk Checklist as a printable PDF.

No spam. We'll only email you about club redevelopment resources.

Want a second set of eyes on your project?

We can help your board turn the right questions into a focused review of your club’s current information and next decisions.